If there is one Filipino actor I admire the most, it would be John Lloyd Cruz. At a very young age, he has already created a niche in the show business as one of the most bankable actors of Philippine Cinema. Personally, I like him because I can relate with his personality: serious, dedicated to work, and very professional. In fact, we have little similarities with our physical features, including our thinning hair line despite our young age.
Few months ago, rumours spread that the young actor will be doing a movie with the Star for All Season, Ms. Vilma Santos, and he will play a gay man’s role. I was excited with this development. I would love to see how Mr. Cruz justifies the role of the oppressed gender. Besides, Vilma Santos is a personal favourite of my mom (may she rest in peace). With this movie, my reunion with mom will somehow materialize with our personal favourites immortalized in the silver screen.
Months passed and the days of waiting finally came to an end when Star Cinema finally released the movie in theatres last Sept. 16, 2009. If it not for work, I would have lined up in cinemas on the first day and be one of the firsts to watch this most talked-about movie of the year. Luckily, the diminutive president declared Monday as national holiday in observance of Ramadan so I got a chance to watch the movie.
I was not satisfied with the movie. Maybe I expected too much from the actors, as they received praises from showbiz personalities like Boy Abunda, and good reviews in newspapers. I haven’t heard a single negative comment from authorities, or maybe Star Cinema was able to manage them and keep them from the public. Or maybe film critics lost their senses of what is good and what is not and was just carried away by the powerhouse cast of the movie.
Story-wise, they have a good storyline: a legally-separated mother with nowhere to go when her children grew up and lived their own lives. But along the way, I found some inconsistencies. Correct if I am wrong but didn’t the landlady asked for her house rent when she’s supposed to own the house, as her only “inheritance” from her ex-husband? Maybe I am wrong. Maybe I did not pay attention to the movie and got carried away by my thinking. But I also cannot help but reflect on how bad she speaks English when she is supposedly a high school librarian cum ex-teacher. Is this reflective of how bad our education system is? Then why highlight in a movie? People will think that it is normal to have librarians and teachers, who are at least a college graduate, who doesn’t even know how to formulate a complete English sentence.
And where is the Filipino value of respect for others when John Lloyd (Noel in the movie) slapped Vilma’s (Shirley Templo) face in the movie, a woman almost twice as your age? Have we ever imagined slapping our mother’s face? His gayness in the movie will never justify this act of disrespect because even in real life, gays do think that they are still men (especially John Lloyd’s character here is a paminta) and they will never fight back with women, no matter how sad and emotional they are. Exchange of chilied words are okay, but not the physically act of hurting somebody. Producers can easily justify the scene, and what about those who think that it is okay to slap an older woman’s face because John Lloyd and Vilma did it in In My Life?
Probably, the most grievous flaw in the movie is when Noel married Shirley just to stabilize his shaky immigration status in the United States (implied). Marriage is a very sacred thing. Marriage is something solemn and should not be used for personal gains or convenience. But the movie rationalized this act, as if telling us to become TNTs and marry an American citizen and divorce them after two years, when we already have green cards. Yes it happens in real life but it should not be put in movies because this is very dangerous and subject to misinterpretation. I think MTRCB should also look at the wrong values portrayed in movies.
On John Lloyd’s acting, as well as Vilma’s, they did very well. I laughed with her witty lines, I sympathized with his melancholic feelings. But Luis (Mark in the movie) still has to prove himself. I don’t like his acting, especially when he was crying in the park with Vilma. It’s very unnatural and emotions were held. If he just gave it in, if would be better. If I were the writer of the movie, it would be good to explore the character of Mark, a well-accomplished yuppie who, in spite of his achievements, was not given proper attention and merit from his parents, or mother, simply because he was gay. Sadly, it was just said, not shown in In My Life.
John Lloyd and Luis’ gay relationship was not well established. There are missing elements, and sex is one good way of showing it (though I doubt if Luis and Lloydie will accept the role if there is an intimate scene). Their “kissing scene” was very, very short, and was given so much publicity but actually it’s nothing.
These are my personal views and actors’ fanatics should not take this against me. I am just sharing these because I want our movie industry to prosper and be laden with values that are truly reflective of the Filipino society. Comments are welcome. Thanks for reading.